New York Red Bulls
Jackson A.
Cheberko Y.
Forsberg E.
Forsberg E.
Meineche M.| New York Red Bulls | 2-3 | Columbus Crew | |
| 2' | 0-1 |
Jackson A. |
|
| 14' | 0-2 |
Cheberko Y. |
|
| 78' |
Forsberg E.
| 1-2 | |
| 87' |
(PK)
Forsberg E.
| 2-2 | |
| 90' | 2-3 |
Meineche M. |
|